Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Ken Taylor's avatar

I think there is a fundamental flaw with this reasoning. It leaves out states, the basic building block of our Republic. Instead, it assumes we are a plebiscite democracy. We are not.

The “We are the majority “ approach resolves into an urban verses rural paradigm. I live in a rural, frontier state. For decades we had a Republican legislature, but elected Democrats to most state offices. This last election the Democrats suffered a clean sweep.

Here is my basic question, why don’t Democrats have a fifty state strategy? Why is it accepted wisdom that Democrats will lose the majority of the states? Why is a split along urban - rural constituencies seen as inevitable?

Certainly the grasping oligarchy has its tentacles in every rural community. Certainly each and every element of our economic and social system are interrelated, interconnected, and in trouble.

What is it that rural and urban communities have in common? Why do we let right wing fear mongering set the terms of the debate? Why do Progressives and Democrats write off rural voters?

Expand full comment
Tom's avatar

Thanks so much for this honest and realistic assessment. The truth is, as disappointed as we are, and as furious as we are at Manchin, we do need to get our elected reps back on their horses to get some things done next year. If we can somehow, next year, pass the climate change portion of BBB, pass the child tax credit even if means tested (not opposed in principle, but the Feds do such a horrible job of means testing, making benefits seem unreachable for those who need it most), and Voting Rights/Election Integrity, then we will still have achieved more than anyone should have expected.

As for us, we have to keep volunteering, working, giving to our max, realizing that the bleaker the potential outcome is, the harder we have to work. I’m going to try to turn disappointment, dejection, and anger into fuel to get things done.

Thanks, Dan, for giving us perspective.

Expand full comment
38 more comments...

No posts